Prophecies Fulfilled: The Qur'anic Arabs in the Early 600s What does a quick change from 'Under consideration' to 'Decision made' back to 'Under consideration' mean for Nature? reach a conclusion of interest to an interdisciplinary readership. Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. My paper has been in that state for over a month, but the editor let us know it was going out for peer review. Reviewing excellence - Boer - Creativity and Innovation Management [CDATA[// >Does "editor decision started" mean rejection in Nature journals? When a journal displays the decision in process status, it means that the editorial board is in the process of making the final decision about your paper. The journal editor will probably make their final decision about your paper based on the changes you now make to the work, as well as the contents, its originality, and the way you write your cover letter. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Although many decisions appear clear-cut, others are necessarily based on subtle distinctions between papers, and referees or editors can sometimes make mistakes. I am currently continuing at SunAgri as an R&D engineer. Rejection is of course a fact of life for all scientists, particularly when they submit their work to highly selective journals; in less than five years since its inception, Nature Neuroscience . Improve the chances of your manuscripts acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. Rejections based on serious errors are frustrating for authors and damaging to the journal's credibility, and so we have a procedure for reconsidering decisions at the author's request. Decisions are quicker, and editorial criteria can be made uniform across disciplines. No news is good news? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Committee for Health, Social Services and Public Safety How long does it take to publish a paper in Journal? [CDATA[> Editorial process : Nature Support All Nature editors report to the Editor of Nature, who sets Nature's publication policies. How to Appeal a Journal Decision - Elsevier Author Services Blog The peer review file is published online as a supplementary peer review file. typoresubmitstagedecision sent to author&, proofproofnaturepublish, ScienceNatureScienceScience, Editor assigned (Peer-review) (discovery) (invention)novelunexpected)The criteria for a paper to be sent for peer-review are that the results seem novel, arresting (illuminating, unexpected or surprising), and that the work described has both immediate and far-reaching implicationsnaturescienceBoard of Reviewing EditorsscienceBoard of Reviewing EditorsBoard of Reviewing EditorsnaturescienceBoard of Reviewing Editorsscienceconnection, 22, Peer-review, Peer-review, 2. The categories includeroughly in order of persuasivenessnew data or analysis, factual errors by referees or editors, disagreement with technical criticisms, evidence of referee bias, procedural concerns and disputes over novelty or significance. However, if it has not gone through peer review, but is directly showing the status awaiting final decision, then there is a possibility that your paper might be rejected after initial screening by the editor. Nature (journal) - Wikipedia Please share with the community how many days the entire process took by the editor's office. It stated 'Under consideration' until today, when it changed to 'Decision made,' and then back to 'Under consideration.' Authors should use the formatting guide section to ensure that the level, length and format (particularly the layout of figures and tables and any Supplementary Information) conforms with Nature's requirements, at submission and each revision stage. In a competitive world, as Gore Vidal put it, It is not enough to succeed. ->Editor assigned->Manuscript under consideration->Editor Decision StartedDecision sent to author->Waiting for revision Make sure that your arguments are backed by solid evidence. What does editor decision started mean nature? Is there a proper earth ground point in this switch box? Yes March 1, 2023 - As we approach, on March 14, its 12-year anniversary, now is as good a time as any to reflect on Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") Rule 206 (4)-5 (the "Pay-to-Play Rule . Full disclosure: Editage Insights is a product of Editage, a global provider of world-class scientific communication solutions. Once the decision has been made to peer-review the paper, the choice of referees is made by the editor who has been assigned the manuscript, who will be handling other papers in the same field, in consultation with editors handling submissions in related fields when necessary. There isnt any secret code to deciphering the submission tracker. queensland figure skating. Did you find it helpful? edit: so no. Editage Insights is funded by Editage and endorses services provided by Editage but is editorially independent. Is it possible to rotate a window 90 degrees if it has the same length and width? All Rights Reserved. If the authors feel that they have a strong scientific case for reconsideration (if the referees have missed the point of the paper, for example) they can appeal the decision in writing. After going through the reviewers comments, the editor will make a decision about your manuscript. Nature (Nature) Was your paper accepted? the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Journals vary in their attitude toward such trade-offs, for example in deciding whether to publish a paper that proposes an important new idea based on data that are less than solid. Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more. A decision of major revisions means you'll need to do some heavier work. My paper was published in a journal in 2021 october. A decision by the editor in chief is the . Confirm that you would also like to sign up for free personalized email coaching for this stage. What does "Editor Decision Started" mean? : r/labrats - reddit The paper is rejected with no offer to reconsider a resubmitted version. Hello. Need help with your experiments? The following decision types are available: Reject; Major revision; Minor revision; Accept; Decisions are communicated to the corresponding author in a formal letter, along with reviewer feedback and any other requirements from the . This enables most queries to be resolved before proof stage. If authors wish to contest an editorial decision, we ask them to submit a form that organizes their arguments into categories that we find useful in reviewing our original judgments. If the editor is satisfied with your work, they will choose appropriate peer reviewers to evaluate your work, taking into account several factors including expertise, experience . We understand your anxiety :-) However, the decision on manuscript acceptance depends on several factors, such as availability and responsiveness of peer reviewers and the extent of revisions recommended. Cactus Communications. Is there a single-word adjective for "having exceptionally strong moral principles"? (You are not allowed to say "Gamma" unless you give a shape and scale parameter). Punnag Ghaisas - Assistant Editor for Discover Journals - LinkedIn Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter what matters in science, free to your inbox daily. Nature has space to publish only 8% or so of the 200 papers submitted each week, hence its selection criteria are rigorous. Status has been "Ready for decision" for 25 days. How long and formal should a paper revision letter to the editor be? But in June 2022, the journal was removed from SCI indexing, what can i do, so much of work in it with two revsions taking more than a year,what can be done, Why is a PhD essential to become a peer-reviewer. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. In light of their advice, I am delighted to say that we can in principle offer to publish it in Nature, provided that you revise the paper to address a number of further editorial points. The Journals and Editorial press office distributes embargoed mailings highlighting upcoming content to registered journalists six days in advance of publication. How much time does the scientific journal 'Nature' take from - Quora Decisions by editors are routinely made very rapidly after receipt of reports, and Nature offers an advance online publication (AOP) service to an increasing number of manuscripts. Once your manuscript passes the initial quality check, we assign it to a member of Editorial Board, who is an active researcher in your field. 1) After submission, the system shows that Manuscript under consideration, which means that it is being evaluated by the editor; 2) If the latest status becomes Editor decision started, it means it has been sent for review (you can also check whether there is reviewer.zip in the file list, if yes, it means it is sent Editor Decision When making a decision, we expect that the academic editor checks the following: The suitability of selected reviewers; Adequacy of reviewer comments and author response; Overall scientific quality of the paper. Does this mean a rejection letter is about to come? Asked by megha m Calm down, and wait a few days before starting your response, then re-read the version of the paper that you actually submitted. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Our subeditors send authors the edited text for approval before it is typeset. v. t. e. Sovereignty generally refers to the supreme authority of a state or territory. Often, Editors reject the manuscript because the analytical approach is not sufficiently rigorous, explicit and argued, or because the results are barely significant or representative. In addition, most authors are genuinely excited about their work, and usually submit to Nature Neuroscience because they believe that the paper deserves high-profile publication. Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? Thus it is not surprising that the first reaction to a rejection letter is often a sense that the editors must have made a mistake. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. ensure that the paper is at the length specified by the manuscript editor (including number of figures). Under these circumstances, the editors letter will state explicitly whether or not a resubmitted version would be considered. Cactus Communications. How to write an email to the editor inquiring about the current status of my paper? At some point, they may come back to you and ask you to suggest names (additional names, if you had already given some when you originally submitted the paper). For more information,please refer to our FAQ page. The paper is accepted for publication in principle once the authors have made some revisions in response to the referees comments. Research suggests that . Can we write a courteous mail asking about the status change from 'Decision Made' to 'Under Consideration'? Editing and proofreading services for a publication-ready manuscript, Customized service packs to match all publication needs, Expert help for all academic translation needs. . If your article is accepted, it could take anywhere from a few months to three years for the journal to publish your piece. Under these circumstances, authors are strongly advised not to resubmit a revised version as it will be declined without further review. Disconnect between goals and daily tasksIs it me, or the industry? Editing and proofreading services for a publication-ready manuscript, Customized service packs to match all publication needs, Expert help for all academic translation needs. How long time should we wait for editor decision on a manuscript? and If an author remains unsatisfied, he or she can write to the Editor, citing the manuscript reference number. While editing corrects the structure of your article whereas a peer reviewer gives you an extensive analysis. Do the revisions and resubmit. A reject decision at this stage is final and cannot be reversed. It only takes a minute to sign up. And "wish you the best in your future endeavors" is the rejection letter equivalent of your crush signing "Have a great summer" in your yearbook. ]]> The editor considers reviewer feedback and their own evaluation of the manuscript in order to reach a decision. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more. To obtain Usually they decide in less than a week after the initial submission. Do roots of these polynomials approach the negative of the Euler-Mascheroni constant? Manuscript rejection: A problem or an opportunity?